The applicability of equitable estoppel scarinci hollenbeck. Us court applies the doctrine of equitable estoppel a recent southern district of new york court ruling took the rare step of applying the doctrine of equitable estoppel to grant coverage in contravention of a marine policys express terms. Equitable estoppel development of the doctrine of equitable estoppel. A patent is a monopoly right granted by a national or regional patent office to an inventor who has created something new, useful and nonobvious. The doctrine of estoppel an attempt to find the answer to these questions through an examination of decided cases leads to several difficulties, not the least of which is the determination of the meaning of estoppel. Overview and historical background of the lear doctrine the lear doctrine stands for the principle that a licensee is not estopped from challenging the validity of a licensed patent in response to allegations of infringement or breach. Pdf doctrine of feeding the grant be estoppel free. The doctrine has been variously called promissory estoppel, equitable estoppel, quasi estoppel and new estoppel. A legal principle that bars a party from denying or alleging a certain fact owing to that partys previous conduct, allegation, or denial. Can a debtors omissions bind a chapter trustee in his pursuit of causes of action to benefit the estate.
An agreement which is contrary to public policy cannot create an estoppel. This principle is commonly invoked in common law in case of breach of contract or against a government. It is theorized that these cases actually represent three different. Pdf the doctrine of promissory estoppel aaditya bhatt. The related principles known as estoppel by record, estoppel by deed, estoppel by representation, promissory estoppel, estoppel against public authority is also considered. But sometimes the strict implementation of low may result in injustice.
It does not allow behaving in one way at a time and in another way at other time. Imagine two united states patents, both with the same inventor, the same drawings, the same written description, the same claims, the same filing date, and the same issuance date. The defendants, high trees, leased a block of flat from the plainti ff s, central london property trust. Estoppel meaning, types and exceptions with case laws. Under such circumstances equity will step in to prevent the injustice. Estoppel is one such concept evolved by equity for rendering justice even deviating from strict legal principles. High trees central london property trust ltd v high trees house ltd 1947 facts. Download doctrine of feeding the grant be estoppel. Accordingly, any person wishing to assert an estoppel must normally come to the court with clean hands. The principle of doctrine of estoppel is stated under section 115 of the indian evidence act, 1892. The property su ff ered from falling occupancy rates due to the outbreak of world war ii in 1940, so the parties agreed to reduce the rent. The doctrine of promissory estoppel prevents one party from withdrawing a promise made to a second party if the latter has reasonably relied.
The doctrine is popularly called as promissory estoppel, equitable estoppel,quasi estoppel and new estoppel. Proprietary estoppel is capable of creating new legal rights in relation to interests in land, whereas promissory estoppel is a negative doctrine only. Doctrine of equivalents and file wrapper estoppel in france. E could be contrasted with private l aw doctrine of estoppel. There is however a distinction between the principle of estoppel by representation and promissory estoppel. As it would cause loss and injury to the person who has acted on such statement. The body of law in a state consists of two parts, substantive and adjective law. In law, the doctrine of estoppel is a legal principle by which a claimant may be prevented from asserting a legal right or depending on a set of facts to support a claim if that claimant has said or done something that contradicts his current claim. Promissory estoppel is the legal principle that a promise is enforceable by law, even if made without formal consideration when a promisor has made a.
New jerseys test for applying judicial estoppel new jersey courts need not adopt or follow the jurisprudence of federal courts regarding the doctrine of judicial estoppel. Courts apply the doctrine of equitable estoppel to prevent. This principle is commonly invoked in common law in case. Renata petrylait can the doctrine of equitable estoppel be applied against a government. The following is an example of a case law defining estoppel by laches. It would be most inequitable and unjust if one person is allowed to speak contrary to his earlier statement. Since the purpose of the doctrine of judicial estoppel is to protect the integrity of the tribunal before which a party seeks to contest. Before addressing the debtors ability to bring certain lawsuits after bankruptcy, it is. You will come across promissory estoppel most commonly in the field of. The doctrine of estoppels is not applicable on questions pertaining to law, such as question of jurisdiction of the court. The doctrine of promissory estoppel allows a party to recover the benefit of a promise made even if a legal contract does not exist. The operation of the principle of estoppel as a bar to prevent a party from acting in a certain.
Estoppel by laches law and legal definition uslegal, inc. Doctrine of equivalents and prosecution history estoppel in the wake of festo case free download as powerpoint presentation. Estoppel is a legal doctrine that prevents a person from adopting a position, action, or attitude, asserting a fact or a right, or prevents one from denying a fact inconsistent with an earlier position if it would result in an injury to someone else. Any invention demands huge investment of time, and resources in the form of research and development.
Equitable estoppel legal definition of equitable estoppel. As noted, equitable estoppel is a defense that is available at both law and equity. Doctrine of estoppel by laches is the neglect or omission to assert a right for an unreasonable and unexplained length of time, under circumstances prejudicial to an adverse party. The rationale behind estoppel is to prevent injustice owing to inconsistency or fraud. Note somewhat uncertain status of promissory estoppel. The right of preemption can be defeated by estoppel, even though it is a legal right. Pdf doctrine of proprietary estoppels munir mughal. Administrative law the proper case for estoppel against. The doctrine is not really based on the principle of estoppel, but it is a doctrine evolved by equity in order to prevent injustice where a promise made by a person.
Doctrine of equivalents and prior history estoppel. The doctrine of promissory estoppel legal service india. Like all equitable remedies, it is discretionary, in contrast to the common law absolute right like right to damages for breach of contract. This term can mean the form of fundamental rules and principles by which a nation or state is governed. Under english law, proprietary and promissory estoppels have quite different elements and remedies. The doctrine of promissory estoppel is an equitable doctrine evolved to avoid injustice and though commonly named promissory estoppel, it falls in the sphere of neither contract nor estoppel. Doctrine of estoppel section 115 evidence law dual. Legal estoppel consists of estoppel by deed and estoppel by record. Promissory estoppel as an independent cause of action susan lorde martin abstract contract rules may be dissolving into torttype notions of unfairness and injustice. For example, the doctrine of estoppel by representation is one and the same whether administered by the court of law or by courts equity. The doctrine of estoppel which may prevent a party from asserting a right is often confused with the doctrine of waiver which relates to.
The doctrine of promissory estoppel is an equitable doctrine. Glossaryestoppelrelated contentin its broadest sense, an equitable doctrine that prevents a party to a lawsuit from asserting a right or fact that is contrary either to. The principle of estoppel is an important concept of the law of evidence. Under the doctrine of estoppel by deed, a party to a property deed is precluded from asserting, as against another party to the deed, any right or title in derogation of the deed, or from denying the truth of any material fact asserted in the deed. The court first acknowledged, under new york law, that an insurer must have promised repeatedly. Judicial estoppel is a discretionary equitable doctrine developed to protect.
Prosecution history estoppel, also known as file wrapper estoppel, is a term used to indicate that a person who has filed a patent application, and then makes narrowing amendments to the application to accommodate the patent law, may be precluded from invoking the doctrine of equivalents to broaden the scope of their claims to cover subject matter ceded by the amendments. Even where the collective agreement or an employer policy clearly does not establish an entitlement, a separate question may arise as to whether fairness would prevent its strict application. The nature of the conduct that forms the basis of the estoppel defense may be either active e. Supreme court formerly hl has yet to confirm existence of doctrine. Whether the doctrine of judicial estoppel applies if the. The doctrine of estoppel under indian evidence act. Preclusion and estoppel doctrines in and out of bankruptcy john rao national consumer law center1 i.
Doctrine of equivalents and prosecution history estoppel. This doctrine attempts to avoid injustice or harm to one party due to inconsistencies of another party. If that employee then proceeds to file for retirement, based on the promise made by the employer, the employer could be legally estopped from not delivering on the payments throughout the course of the former employees retirement. Estoppel can only refer to the facts not on the point of law. The doctrine of promissory estoppel application to the. Courts apply the doctrine of equitable estoppel to prevent employers from skirting liability for their actions toward otherwise ineligible employees. The doctrine has been variously described as equitable estoppel, quasi estoppel and new estoppel. Estoppel, originated from the sense of justice, equity and good consciousness has since developed through various judicial pronouncements. There is no place of contradicting a thing said in the law of evidence. Traditionally, promissory estoppel was viewed as a substitute for consideration in situations where promisors.
1268 561 222 341 587 1317 1340 1024 955 618 760 957 1160 904 166 888 601 805 876 733 1427 913 989 1414 32 1039 705 371 450 28 593 1548 1177 1112 35 346 731 132 1147 742 1179 387 62